UPDATED 13:44 EST / OCTOBER 27 2011

Processor Wars – Intel Under Seige From ARM – Even Steve Jobs Chose ARM over Intel

There is a massive chip war going on right now between the market leader Intel verses upstart ARM Holdings.

ARM today disclosed technical details of its new ARMv8 architecture, the first ARM architecture to include a 64-bit instruction set.

The ARM architecture is unique in its ability to span the full range of electronic devices and equipment, from tiny sensors through to large scale infrastructure equipment. The new ARMv8 architecture will expand the reach of ARM processor-based solutions into consumer and enterprise applications where extended virtual addressing and 64-bit data processing are required.

ARM processors are ideal for smartphones and computing devices that require superior power management which now includes data center servers.

Just yesterday Don Clark of the Wall Street Journal wrote that Steve Jobs Wanted Intel Chips for the iPad but chose ARM.

According to Walter Isaacson’s biography of Steve Jobs, Steve pushed for Intel processors in the iPad. With the focus of small faster cheaper, heat and power management becomes the biggest obstacles for the chip makers. Whoever cracks that code for mobile and datacenters wins the war. Right now Intel holds 90% market share and ARM is pushing at them hard.

Here is what Don Clark reported.

Intel at the time was developing its low-powered Atom chip, which Jobs favored, Isaacson writes. Intel CEO Paul Otellini was pushing hard to work with Apple on the tablet, and Jobs was inclined to trust him.

But Tony Fadell–then a key leader of Apple’s design efforts, now at the startup Nest Labs–was adamant that the iPad needed the even lower power consumption of chips based on designs from ARM Holdings. He felt so strongly about the matter that, during one meeting, he placed his Apple badge on the table and threatened to resign over the matter, according to the biography.

Jobs eventually relented. Indeed, Apple became such a zealot for ARM that it began designing its own chips based on the technology, using an engineering team acquired by buying the startup P.A. Semi.

The biography also includes some sharp criticism by Jobs of Intel, at least beyond its high-performance microprocessors for PCs. Intel, Jobs said, had wanted to do a “big joint project” with Apple to do chips for future iPhones but was not selected.

“There were two reasons we didn’t go with them,” Jobs said, according to the book. “One was that they are just really slow. They are like a steamship, not very flexible. We’re used to going pretty fast. Second is that we just didn’t want to teach them everything, which they could go and sell to our competitors.”

Isaacson includes Otellini’s rebuttal to this account. The real issue, Intel’s CEO told him, is that Apple and Intel couldn’t agree on chip pricing. The companies also disagreed on who would control the design–another example, the author concludes, of Jobs’s compulsion to control every aspect of a product.

Elsewhere in the biography, Isaacson recounts how Jobs and Otellini had gotten to know each other in the 1990s when Jobs was struggling to sustain his second company, NeXT, and “his arrogance had been temporarily tempered,” as Otellini put it. Later, at Apple, Jobs pushed for the pivotal move in 2005 to start using Intel chips for the Macintosh, after years using the PowerPC technology promoted by IBM and Motorola.

Chip pricing in those days was also a key issue, with Jobs wanting better terms than other computer makers, the biography discloses. Jobs and Otellini would take walks together above the Stanford University campus, starting with broad pronouncements by Jobs about the evolution of computing. By the end of the walk, Jobs would be haggling over price, Isaacson writes.


A message from John Furrier, co-founder of SiliconANGLE:

Your vote of support is important to us and it helps us keep the content FREE.

One click below supports our mission to provide free, deep, and relevant content.  

Join our community on YouTube

Join the community that includes more than 15,000 #CubeAlumni experts, including Amazon.com CEO Andy Jassy, Dell Technologies founder and CEO Michael Dell, Intel CEO Pat Gelsinger, and many more luminaries and experts.

“TheCUBE is an important partner to the industry. You guys really are a part of our events and we really appreciate you coming and I know people appreciate the content you create as well” – Andy Jassy

THANK YOU