Analysis: Microsoft Is Squandering Its Hyper-V Opportunity

Last week, Chad Sakac released his My Crystal Ball for 2013 article in which he discussed his top 10 industry prognostications about what he sees as happening in 2013.  His analysis runs the gamut from the hypervisor to the cloud to Hadoop to convergence and more.  There was one item, however, that caught my attention and for which I wanted to provide some of my own thoughts:

“Hyper-V 3 in Windows Server 2012 is potent.   While still far from the capabilities of VMware overall (things like Storage DRS as an example, VDP, vSphere Replication, etc), it catches up on so many, and even surpasses on some (like the frustrating 2TB VMDK limit).  So why won’t it surge?   In my opinion, Microsoft can’t seem to get out of its own way.   The various business units like SQL Server, SharePoint, and Exchange can’t seem to get their heads wrapped around how advantageous it could be if they embraced the Windows Core team and Hyper-V.   I’m talking about more than just “works with”, more like “works better with”.   At least, make Hyper-V the centerpiece of the go-to-market – the underlying “strata” for Microsoft-centric enterprises… And yet, they just don’t.  I don’t get it.”

Chad is a smart guy and he’s spot on with his analysis regarding Hyper-V 3.  Personally, as the title of this post indicates, I believe that Microsoft is completely squandering their significant opportunity with Hyper-V 3.  Hyper-V 3 is a massive leap forward from the Hyper-V that shipped with Windows Server 2008 R2 and brings to the hypervisor enterprise grade capability that makes it a real contender in the space.

I don’t think that Microsoft realizes that IT workloads no longer run on servers built by Dell, HP, IBM and other vendors.  Today’s workloads run on the hypervisor abstraction layer that separates running workloads from the underlying hardware.  Server vendors are simply providing a commodity product to facilitate this abstraction.  Want proof?  Open any virtual machine running on vSphere and take a look at that virtual machine’s platform details and you’ll see references to the processor and to vSphere, but nary a mention of any physical server vendor.
From this perspective, VMware currently owns the server market and that should worry Microsoft.  VMware is working hard to delve further and further into the application space, which Microsoft currently owns, not to mention potential damage that could be inflicted by the likes of Google, although I don’t believe that Google will ever truly understand the enterprise.

How has Microsoft squandered their potential with regard to Hyper-V 3?  Let me count the ways:

  1. Holding System Center 2012 SP1 for two full months after Windows Server 2012/Hyper-V 3 RTM.  I fully understand the need and the desire to get the software right, but Microsoft was out there battling VMware with an unsupported solution based on beta software!  And the pundits, many of whom are squarely in VMware’s corner, didn’t let the company forget it.
  2. Bundling System Center into a single suite.  I believe that this was a strategic mistake by the company.  While the components will likely become more integrated over time, it’s a shame that those interested in Hyper-V 3 can’t just buy Virtual Machine Manager 2012 at a lower cost than the full bundle.  Given Microsoft’s need to capture hypervisor market share, creating what might appear to be a more substantial barrier to entry did not seem to be in the best interests of the company.  System Center is a complex beast and some organizations may not want to use all of the pieces.  This decision could force organizations to buy software they don’t want or need.  Personally, I think Microsoft would have been better served to change the product bundling once Hyper-V was a hit.
  3. The company isn’t continuing to scream Hyper-V everything at the top of its lungs. While I believe that Microsoft should continue to support all reasonable hypervisors, every unit at Microsoft should be ordered – yes, ordered – to make Hyper-V 3 the platform of choice for everything that the company sells.  Provide customers with exacting guidance around Hyper-V 3 for everything and make Hyper-V the first-class citizen that it deserves to be.
  4. Publicly fighting with VMware over features and capabilities.  Just… STOP.  Let the product sell itself… and it can!  It’s capable and is an impressive display of what the company can do when they’re behind the curve.  While it may not be quite up to VMware standards in every way, it is more than capable and beats VMware in others.  The battle of the blogs over vSphere vs. Hyper-V just serve to remind people that there is a difference.

With a new year comes a new opportunity for Microsoft to push Hyper-V 3 on all fronts, particularly now that System Center 2012 SP1 has hit RTM.  If history serves as a guide, this is Microsoft’s battle to lose.  If they can execute well, perhaps Microsoft can topple vSphere as the world’s largest server provider.

23 Comments

  1. @hvredevoort For what it’s worth, we dumped System Center to get HyperV in production. It’s a great hyper visor.

  2. @hvredevoort Maybe Windows should be a part of Hyper-V instead of the other way around.

  3. @hvredevoort and he guy was being nice saying 2 months , GA in september and we are in decemeber and still no GA for SP1

  4. @hvredevoort Thinking about it, it could deliberate. #antitrust

  5. @WorkingHardInIT @hvredevoort pretty good analysis. Don’t agree 100% but some stuff mirrors what I’ve been saying.

  6. @tmels @hvredevoort Hyper-V should in my opinion be part of the system ce

  7. @tmels @hvredevoort Hyper-V should be part if System Center in my opinion. sysctr and hypervisor provides tools for the content holding vms

  8. @FredrikNilsson_ Hyper-V and System Center should amplify each other, not hinder it.

  9. @hvredevoort I strongly agree. I think that we will see change in that.

  10. @joe_elway @WorkingHardInIT @hvredevoort Guys you’re right but remember the legal issues. If MS integrates more then monopoly rules kick in

  11. This site is truly amazing my one of friend told me about this. And the theme is quite beautiful as well as the updated stuff also attract visitors to coma and visit again. I would definitely bookmark it and would come back to you soon. Keep on updating.
    <a href=”http://howiphone.net/”>http://howiphone.net/ </a>

  12. This site is truly amazing my one of friend told me about this. And the theme is quite beautiful as well as the updated stuff also attract visitors to coma and visit again. I would definitely bookmark it and would come back to you soon. Keep on updating.
    http://howiphone.net/

  13. The Blog you are running is just awesome. The stuff and theme of the blog is so impressive. The actual match, like your blog, is found on very rare places. This blog is so clear and simple, there is no useless content you have added just to show a fake knowledge about the topic. I am new to blogging and picking lot from your blog.
    Thanks a lot!!!

  14. The Blog you are running is just awesome. The stuff and theme of the blog is so impressive. The actual match, like your blog, is found on very rare places. This blog is so clear and simple, there is no useless content you have added just to show a fake knowledge about the topic. I am new to blogging and picking lot from your blog. Here, http://how-to.in ,is my blog if you want to take a look and do suggest me if any problem or something missing.
    Thanks a lot!!!

  15. Seems to be a perfect place to learn something new.. Here I can pick many things for my blog as I have recently created and its in progress. My blog is totally different from your blog. But still I want the admin to suggest me that how can I attract visitors to increase traffic. Have a look here, http://free-songs.org/ on my blog and do suggest me if there is any requirement for any change. I would be really glad and any suggestions would be appreciated. Thanks in advance!!!!

  16. Thanks for sharing about above topic. My one of friend told me about this. And the theme is quite beautiful as well as the updated stuff also attract visitors to visit <a href=”http://georama.gr/”>this site</a> again. I would definitely bookmark it and would come back to you soon. Keep on updating.

  17. Thanks for sharing this information really informative. Somehow I reached here while browsing. But when I gone through your Blog.. It’s awesome. I would like to subscribe your updates via E-mail. Keep on updating. Have bookmarked for future visit and discussion also.

  18. Thanks for sharing this information really informative. Somehow I reached at <a href=”etba.gr/”>this site</a> while browsing. But when I gone through your Blog.. It’s awesome. I would like to subscribe your updates via E-mail. Keep on updating. Have bookmarked for future visit and discussion also.

  19. Thanks for sharing this information really informative. Somehow I reached at this site while browsing. But when I gone through your Blog.. It’s awesome. I would like to subscribe your updates via E-mail. Keep on updating. Have bookmarked for future visit and discussion also.
    http://etba.gr/

  20. Nice work on this site. I enjoyed the discussion. I would like to subscribe your updates via E-mail Or have bookmarked your site. Keep it going on to be followed for more updates. I would be visiting again very soon.
     
    http://www.knit-edu.com

  21. This is what !!! I can call a perfect blog with perfect contents and a quite beautiful theme. Here I can see a perfect match of theme, font and content. The topic also relates to the most searchable keywords and is described so clearly.

  22. This is what !!! I can call a perfect blog with perfect contents and a quite beautiful theme. Here I can see a perfect match of theme, font and content. The topic also relates to the most searchable keywords and is described so clearly.
     http://rsmdc.org

  23. Seems you had put many efforts while creating this site. But now its being a long time you have updated some interesting stuff, I have noticed as I am visiting this site again.I wan you to update it by sharing about some latest and hot topic.
     
    http://bank-omb.gr

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>