UPDATED 07:48 EDT / DECEMBER 23 2014

Judge refuses to lift Autonomy albatross from HP’s neck

Rime of the Ancient MarinerThe botched acquisition of Autonomy Corp., keeps coming back to haunt Hewlett-Packard Co.. Three years and a leadership change after plunking down $11.7 billion for the British analytics provider, HP has hit another legal stumbling block as a U.S. District Judge on Friday rejected a settlement that would have released company executives from culpability. Judge Charles Breyer had previously struck down a similar deal in August on the grounds that it diminished the rights of investors to take legal action against the vendor.

When HP originally revealed the acquisition as part of an effort to grow software revenues in August of 2011, the deal immediately received harsh criticism from pundits and even competitors who argued that it was overpriced, a view that many insiders shared but apparently not the board of directors. The real problems started a year later when it became clear that the company not only paid more than it should have but also received considerably less than it anticipated in return.

Autonomy had reported significantly greater revenue than it actually generated, a discrepancy that HP CEO Whitman blamed on “serious accounting improprieties” in a conference call with investors two years later. But shareholders were not satisfied to let the company shrug off responsibility, especially after HP took an 8.8 billion writedown to cover its losses.

Investors have since lost some of their interest in holding HP’s top-brass accountable for the botched purchase, but Judge Breyer has not been as forgiving. He said the terms of the settlement would have shielded the HP leadership from “all known claims” concerning not only the Autonomy deal but also a long list of past and future actions, effectively barring shareholders from suing the firm. That, he wrote, is unfair when a “whole universe” of potential lawsuits exist regarding the company’s business conduct.

Breyer also called into question the value of the governance reforms that investors would have received in return for releasing HP’s management from liability. The ruling leaves the company with only one more chance to hammer out an out-of-court settlement.

Image via Wikimedia Commons

A message from John Furrier, co-founder of SiliconANGLE:

Support our open free content by sharing and engaging with our content and community.

Join theCUBE Alumni Trust Network

Where Technology Leaders Connect, Share Intelligence & Create Opportunities

11.4k+  
CUBE Alumni Network
C-level and Technical
Domain Experts
15M+ 
theCUBE
Viewers
Connect with 11,413+ industry leaders from our network of tech and business leaders forming a unique trusted network effect.

SiliconANGLE Media is a recognized leader in digital media innovation serving innovative audiences and brands, bringing together cutting-edge technology, influential content, strategic insights and real-time audience engagement. As the parent company of SiliconANGLE, theCUBE Network, theCUBE Research, CUBE365, theCUBE AI and theCUBE SuperStudios — such as those established in Silicon Valley and the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) — SiliconANGLE Media operates at the intersection of media, technology, and AI. .

Founded by tech visionaries John Furrier and Dave Vellante, SiliconANGLE Media has built a powerful ecosystem of industry-leading digital media brands, with a reach of 15+ million elite tech professionals. The company’s new, proprietary theCUBE AI Video cloud is breaking ground in audience interaction, leveraging theCUBEai.com neural network to help technology companies make data-driven decisions and stay at the forefront of industry conversations.